' LIS 450RR: Evaluation Rating Form

LIS 450RRL: GRANTWRITING AND FUNDRAISING

Evaluation Rating Form

  
Below is a form for you to use in rating one of your colleague's proposals. Please provide a numerical rating for each of the proposal components listed below. Note the scoring system is based on a scale of 100.

In scoring, consider how many points represent outstanding, superior, adequate, weak or a poor score. For example, if the total points possible are 25, then 2-8=poor, 9-12=weak, 13-19=adequate, 20-23=superior, and 24-25=outstanding. If the total points possible are 15, then 0-3=poor, 4-6=weak, 7-9=adequate, 10-12=adequate, 13-15=outstanding. If the total point possible are 10, then 0-2=poor, 3-4=weak, 5-6=adequate, 7-8=superior, and 9-10=outstanding.

I will share your review with the person or persons whose proposal you are evaluating but will keep your name confidential UNLESS you tell me it's ok to give your name to the individual(s) in case they wish further clarification. Please check this box ONLY IF YOU ARE WILLING FOR ME TO TELL WHO WROTE THE REVIEW. Otherwise, I will NOT share this information and your review will be read by your colleague(s) anonymously. Please check this box if you wish me to tell your colleague who reviewed their proposal.

If you have questions, please email me at Evelyn Daniel.

Hit the Send key at the bottom of the page when you have finished entering. If you wish to start over, hit RESTART.

Name:
First Name:
Last Name:

Section Number:

Short Title of Proposal Reviewed:

Name(s) of Writers(s):


Proposal Components and Point Value

Need for Project (25 points) -- Your Rating

Comment on Need:

Concept (10 points) -- Your Rating

Comment on Concept:

Plan of Operation (15 points) -- Your Rating

Comment on Plan of Operation:

Key Personnel (10 points) -- Your Rating

Comment on Key Personnel:

Evaluation Plan (15 points) -- Your Rating

Comment on Evaluation:

Budget and Cost Effectiveness (10 points) -- Your Rating

Comment on Budget and Cost Effectiveness:

Significance and Likely Impact (20 points) -- Your Rating

Comment on Significance and Impact:


My recommendation is that this proposal should be:


Thank you for providing this information.

Revised 6/5/2001