Erica C. Jarvis
10/12/00
INLS 121
Dr. Sturm
Story Cue Card
Preschool
Bibliographic Information (best version for telling): The Three Billy Goats Gruff. In The Troll with no Heart in His Body: and Other Tales of Trolls from Norway retold by Lise Lunge-Larsen. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1999.
Ethnic Origin: Norway
Running Time: 5 – 7 minutes
Power Center(s): The story
has three power centers. Whether the
emphasis is placed on the first, second or third power center depends on from
whose point of view the story is told.
The first power surge occurs when the tinniest Billy Goat Gruff is
driven by fear and hunger to outwit the Troll. The second power surge occurs
when the middle Billy Goat Gruff is also driven by his fear and hunger to
outwit the Troll. The third power
center occurs when the biggest Billy Goat Gruff is driven by hunger and a need
to protect his brothers to rid his family forever of the hideous Troll.
Why I choose these power centers: In order to enjoy telling this story, I had to understand why the Billy Goats Gruff decided to cross the bridge to go to the lush green meadow in the first place. I decided that my Billy Goats Gruff had to be motivated by a very strong hunger. This hunger then enables the tinniest and middle Billy Goat Gruffs to overcome their fears of the Troll and attempt to cross the bridge. I could just as easily have said the goats were motivated by greed for a better meadow but this idea did not appeal to me as much. Also central to my telling of the story, is the notion that I am telling it from the point of view of the biggest Billy Goat Gruff. Therefore the highest power surge occurs when he rids his family of the Troll forever. This interpretation of the story helps me come to grips with the violence preformed by the biggest Billy Goat Gruff against the Troll. The violence just does not bother me as much if the biggest Billy Goat Gruff is motivated by a need to protect his family (or even to fix what his family members have let slide). A different teller could just as easily tell this story from the point of view of the tinniest Billy Goat Gruff, the middle Billy Goat Gruff, or even the Troll.
Characters: Troll, tinniest Billy Goat Gruff, middle Billy Goat Gruff, biggest Billy Goat Gruff
Scenes:
1. A mountain – (three Billy goats Gruff, of varying sizes, are on their way to a lush green meadow but must first pass over a stone bridge)
2. Stone bridge – (tinniest Billy Goat is threatened by Troll)
3. Stone bridge – (middle Billy Goat is threatened by Troll)
4. Stone bridge – (biggest Billy Goat is threatened by Troll and fights back)
Synopsis: The three Billy Goats Gruff want to go to a lush
green meadow. In order to get there,
they have to cross a bridge inhabited by a horrible Troll. When the tinniest Billy Goat Gruff crosses
the bridge he convinces the Troll that he, the tinniest Billy Goat, is much too
small to eat. The middle Billy Goat
Gruff also convinces the Troll not to eat him because he is also too
small. When the Troll tries to eat the
biggest Billy Goat Gruff, the oldest brother decides to rid his family of the
Troll forever. Once all three Billy
Goats Gruff arrive in the meadow, they eat and eat until they become too fat to
go home.
Special phrases are used a lot in all the versions of The Three Billy Goats Gruff. These special phrases are emphasized even more because they are repeated again and again. The first special phrase, “tripp, trapp, tripp, trapp” is used to emulate the sound that the Goats hooves make as they cross the stone bridge. One can experiment with how the phrase is said and turn it into something more like a sound affect. The second special phrase that gets repeated over and over is used to describe the Troll. The narrator says that the Troll had “eyes as big as saucers and a nose as long as a poker.” Through facial expressions and voice intonation one can also experiment with this phrase. The final special phrase is also a rhyme. The line, “snip, snap, snout. This tale’s told out!” is used to close the story.
Audience (why is this story appropriate for the audience?
Developmental characteristics?):
One reason I chose this
story for the preschool (3-5) age group is because in her book, Storytelling:
Art & Technique, Ellin Green said it was appropriate for this age
group. One can also find justification
for its use with this age group in the “Child’s Developmental Growth”
handout. In the Erik Erikson section it
says that, “imaginative play helps children [in this age group] gain sense of
the roles and institutions of society.”
In the story, place in family is very important. The listener is taught that an elder family
member will look out for him/her when something bad happens (like when a
hideous Troll threatens to eat you).
This story also seems appropriate for this age group when one looks at
the Abraham Maslow section. The second
need on Maslow’s hierarchy is a need for safety. The story begins with “once upon a time…” and ends with “snip,
snap, snout. This tale’s told out”
helps set the story in a make believe world as opposed to a present day
world. The fact that this story is
clearly set out side of the present time should help a child in this age group
feel safe even though the story does have a very violent ending. According to Piaget’s developmental stages
section, repetition is very important for the two to seven age group. This story is full of repetition (i.e.
“tripp, trapp, tripp, trapp” and “eyes as big as saucers and a nose as long as
a poker”). In the Charlotte Huck
section of the handout, it says that children in this age group have a “short
attention span.” This story can be told
well in five to seven minutes. Ms. Huck
also says that for this age group a “fantasy world is very real.” Children 3-5 should love this story about
talking Billy Goats and Trolls, things that are very much a part of a
fantastical world. In addition, Ms.
Huck also says that children in this age group make “absolute judgments of
right and wrong.” This story will fit
well into their need for no gray areas.
In The Three Billy Goats Gruff the goats are good, the Troll is
bad, and everyone gets their just desserts (the goats get fat and the Troll
gets thrown in the river).
Bibliographic Information on other versions/variants (at
least two): The Three Billy-Goats Gruff. In The Random House Children’s Treasury
told by Peter C. Asbjørnsen and Jørgen E. Moe.
New York: Derrydale Books, 1998.
The Three Billy Goats
Bruse. In The Boy Who Ate More
Than the Giant and Other Swedish Folktales retold by Ulf Löfgren. New York: William Collins + World Publishing
Company, 1978. (Swedish)
The Three Goats. In Tales
of Laughter: a Third Fairy Book edited by Kate Douglas Wiggin and Nora Archibald Smith. Garden City, NY: Doubleday, Page & Company, 1927. (German)
Three Billy Goats
Gruff. In Once Upon a Bedtime Story retold by Jane Yolen Honesdale, PA: Boyds Bill Press, Inc., 1997.
Brief comparison of all versions/variants in terms of language, rhythm, “tellability,” “flavor,” content, etc. Stress the differences in style rather than those of content:
I chose to include three versions and two variants in
this cue card. The Asbjørnsen and Moe,
Lunge-Larsen, Yolen versions all tell basically the same story. The Asbjørnsen and Moe version is probably
the most famous version. Most of the
special phrases and rhymes occur in this version. The Asbjørnsen and Moe version also adds a rhyme that does not
appear in all the versions. That rhyme
is probably the most violent line in any of the versions and it reads:
Well,
come along! I’ve got two spears,
And
I’ll poke your eyeballs out at your ears:
I’ve
got besides, two curling-stones,
And
I’ll crush you to bits, body and bones.
The Lunge-Larsen version
expands a little upon the Asbjørnsen and Moe version while the Yolen version
expands upon it a lot. The Asbjørnsen
and Moe version tells the basic story.
In the Lunge-Larsen version it is very clear that fear is motivating the
tinniest and middle Billy Goats Gruff.
In the Yolen version the dialog and descriptions are developed a lot
more than the other versions. My
favorite line from the Yolen version is:
Now,
trolls may be mean. And trolls may be
green. But trolls are also very, very
stupid.
One can just hear the
children squeal with delight when the word stupid is used. In the Yolen version, it also becomes
clearer that the Troll is being manipulated the goats.
I
originally said I would tell this story because I knew it was appropriate for
the age group. I chose it because I was
having trouble finding something that both I would enjoy telling and 3 to 5
year children would enjoy listening to.
Then one day I found the Jane Yolen version. As I was reading the story to myself, I found that it had to be
read out loud. So I read it to my dog
and he actually listened! In Ms.
Yolen’s version the characters are developed more than in any of the other
versions or variants. As I read the
story out loud, I began to visualize in my head how I could use my face, body,
arms, and voice to help tell the story.
Unfortunately, because her version is so long I have had to give up a
lot of her character development in a telling for 3 to 5 year olds. However, I have a paper copy stored in a
folder and a mental copy stored in my head in case I have the opportunity to
tell this story to slightly older children.
There
were two variants of this story a German one and a Swedish one. The variants are only slightly different
than the Asbjørnsen and Moe version. In
the German version the goats are name Brausewind, the troll is actually an elf,
and the language is slightly different.
The German version uses “creak, creak” instead of “tripp, trapp, tripp,
trapp” and it really is not as effective.
Also the elf or horrible spirit has “eyes as wide as pewter plates” and
a nose “as long as the handle of a hoe” which just seems a little to verbose
for the age group. The four-line rhyme
used by the biggest Billy Goat to taunt the Troll is slightly different but
just as violent. Finally, the wonderful
“snip, snap, snout…” ending does not appear in this version. In the Swedish variant the goats are named
Bruse and the language is slightly different.
Instead of “tripp, trapp, tripp, trapp” they goats hooves make a
“clip-clop, clip-clop, clip-clop” noise which I find almost as appealing as the
other version. Another difference is
that the Troll has “eyes as big as plates and a nose as long as a broom
handle.” The image is okay but it does
not roll off the tongue in the same way.
The rhyme taunting the troll becomes just a spoken line in this
variant. Finally, the story ends “and
clippety, clip-clop, this tale’s come to a stop” which I do enjoy. On the whole all the versions and variants
were very similar. The differences
tended to be minor changes in language, further developing of descriptions, and
variations in the length of dialogs.